Kit Seelye over at The NYT issues a bleg:
I’m writing a small column item for Monday’s Caucus blog about why more men seemed to be involved in politics online than women. I wondered if you 1) agreed with that and 2) why or why not.
This results in a comment thread that’s about as interesting as these things usually are, until we get to comment 41, where someone says something worth listening to, and which is worth reprinting in full:
Oh where to begin.
First let me say that I do not agree that more men than woman are involved on politics online – only that the men are louder, brasher and more apt to get attention from mainstream publications.
They are also more apt to support one and another, to link to each other repeatedly and build up an echo chamber that reinforces their dominance.
If you are talking about the political blogosphere, then indeed, you are likely talking about a cluster of well-known blogs that are dominated by men. Others will claim that this is not so – they will point to the fact that DailyKos has female contributors. I’d counter that we’ve not seen those women on “Meet the Pressâ€. They’d point to the Huffington Post and Arianna’s success – I’d counter that Arianna is the face – an establishment figure who lent her name and commentary to a media venture created and funded by a man. Or they’ll point to FireDogLake and Jane Hamsher – whose blog has a cadre of diverse writers – which is the exception not the rule.
The truth is that when it comes to online politics many women have largely rejected the outfront role of blogging for the behind the scenes work of organizing – which brings with it infintely more satisfaction but sincerely less notoriety. For examples of this look to Gina Cooper, the founder and driving force behind the YearlyKos Convention, which was responsible in a large part for giving credibility to the men who are so often considered, “the blogosphereâ€. Or look to Speaker Pelosi’s office – where the internet operation has been run by a highly capable woman, Karina Newton for years. Other examples can be found in non-profits, campaigns and organizations where women have risen through the ranks of online organizing. Look at the New Organizing Institutes’s former executive director Roz LeMieux and current president Judith Freeman. Look at Zephyr Teachout from Dean 2004 and Amanda Michel now over at NewAssignment.net. These women are there – but they are often more powerful behind the scenes, building, organizing and actually making things happen.
This behind the scenes role can also be attributed to the large amount of sexism prevalent online that female bloggers deal with day in and day out, especially when they have the nerve to venture forward with a strong informed opinion.
However, to really find the women en mass you have to look beyond the incestuous political blogosphere (see Garance for more on that: http://thegarance.com/archives/768) to the larger blogosphere. There you will find the feminist bloggers, largely disconnected from the political blogosphere, despite their liberal leanings. These women have been blogging for years, yet are rarely linked to by the male-dominated political blogosphere – though there are a few exceptions, the occasional rant of Amanda Marcotte, more famous post-Edwards, when the “bloggers†could claim her as one of their own, Feministing.com’s brash Jessica Valenti, author of a new book, who has achieved a good deal of cross-blogosphere pollination in the past year and the odd crosspost over on HuffPo.
You could also look toward the Mommy Bloggers – a sphere where Silicon Valley Mom Blog and affiliates meet with Elizabeth Edwards and no one in the political sphere notices, or where BlogHer brings over a thousand woman to Chicago the same week as the YearlyKos convention but the political campaigns scarcely notice, despite an entire track devoted to politics.
The truth is woman are out there and they are frustrated that the media constantly cites the same loud men as representatives of the blogosphere. These men have done some good things, that is true – but they have not done everything and it’s time someone recognized that.
The women are there, if you care to notice them.
— Posted by a woman on the inside
Whoever you are, we should have lunch.